Why were the Founders so excellent and our modern leaders so awful? Because they cultivated and developed themselves into great men rather than relying on credentialism and technocracy. This episode discusses the Virginia gentry as a ruling class that developed itself in virtue, duty, and the skill of governance through a structured sequence of responsibilities–the “cursus honorum” of the Virginia gentry.
As a reminder, these history episodes are provided ad-free to paid subscribers. If you would like to do so, you can click here or click below. You can also listen on YouTube or Spotify!
This development began with the plantation, where competence was judged publicly through the quality of the tobacco crop and the condition of the estate. From there, the Virginia gentleman went on to serve in local church vestries, county courts, and the House of Burgesses, and eventually national politics, such as the American Revolution’s Continental Congress.
We use that to show how Virginians were expected to prove themselves at each level before advancing further. We then compare this Virginia system with the Roman cursus honorum, the progression from military service to questor, aedile, praetor, senate service, and consul upon which the Roman elite embarked. We discuss the two systems of tiered elite formation, and why they are necessary in building an aristocratic republic that functions well, emphasizing that both systems tied status to duty, training, and public service rather than to wealth alone.
We then contrast the Virginia gentry with later American elites, especially the WASP and technocratic classes of the Gilded Age through modernity, arguing that these newer elites became rootless, moved away from the communities that formed them, and relied more on abstract credentials, institutions, and centralized systems. Trusts, Ivy League education, and modern managerial structures are discussed as examples of this shift, and how it is deleterious.
Overall, we discuss whether a modern version of this kind of aristocratic development could be rebuilt. The speakers argue that tiered institutions, family continuity, local cooperation, and visible standards of conduct could still create a leadership class. We also discuss how AI, surveillance technology, and financial change may make personal quality and judgment more visible, while warning that technology alone cannot solve problems without the right character in the people who use it.
Read the referenced article on the cursus honorum here: https://www.theamericantribune.news/p/equality-and-the-only-political-question
Listen to the previous episode here: https://www.theamericantribune.news/p/the-virginia-gentry-how-americas
Read the referenced article on building aristocracy here: https://www.theamericantribune.news/p/embodying-aristocratic-excellence
Read the referenced article on architecture here: https://www.theamericantribune.news/p/the-architecture-of-american-renewal
Sources Referenced in this Episode:
I am an Amazon Affiliate. If you would like to support the show at no added cost to yourself, you can do so by using the links below to order and read the sources I used to create this episode. Thanks!
Billings, Warren M., Sir William Berkeley and the Forging of Colonial Virginia, https://amzn.to/4c9LrER
Breen, T. H., Tobacco Culture, https://amzn.to/4wNrigt
Bridenbaugh, Carl, Myths and Realities: Societies of the Colonial South, https://amzn.to/4wybkqi
Bridenbaugh, Carl, Seat of Empire:, https://amzn.to/45q3nr4
Bruce, Philip Alexander, Economic History of Virginia in the Seventeenth Century, https://amzn.to/4pLWjOM
Bruce, Philip Alexander, Institutional History of Virginia in the Seventeenth Century, https://amzn.to/4pIGUPj
Bruce, Philip Alexander, Social Life of Virginia in the Seventeenth Century, https://amzn.to/4wF4LlJ
Burt, Nathaniel, First Families: The Making of an American Aristocracy, https://amzn.to/44LGdLF
Carson, Jane, Colonial Virginians at Play
Evans, Emory G., A Topping People, https://amzn.to/4xaSQfj
Fischer, David Hackett, Albion’s Seed, https://amzn.to/4xaSKUZ
Isaac, Rhys, The Transformation of Virginia, 1740–1790, https://amzn.to/4ftuyr2
Hendrick, Burton J., The Lees of Virginia, https://amzn.to/4pFM2Ut
Rasmussen, William M. S., Old Virginia, https://amzn.to/4bne0yu
Sydnor, Charles S., Gentlemen Freeholders: Political Practices in Washington’s Virginia, https://amzn.to/45nNe5o
Wright, Louis B., The First Gentlemen of Virginia, https://amzn.to/4vXmOlU